๐ Stop Payment Notices (California)
On public projects, you can't file a mechanics lien against government property. A stop payment notice is your primary remedy โ it freezes construction funds until your claim is resolved.
Stop payment notices freeze construction funds. On public works they're your primary remedy. On private work with a construction loan, they're a powerful supplement to your mechanics lien.
What Is a Stop Payment Notice?โ
Under California Civil Code ยงยง8500-8538 (private) and ยงยง9350-9364 (public), a stop payment notice is a written demand served on:
- The public entity (on public works)
- The construction lender (on private projects with a construction loan)
It directs them to withhold funds sufficient to pay your claim. Unlike a mechanics lien, it doesn't attach to property โ it freezes money owed to the contractor.
When Stop Payment Notices Applyโ
Public Works Projectsโ
Use on any government-funded project in Silicon Valley:
- City of San Jose, Sunnyvale, Palo Alto, Mountain View projects
- Santa Clara County projects
- Caltrans and state projects
- School districts (SCCOE, individual districts)
- Special districts (VTA, Valley Water, etc.)
Why: You can't lien government property, so stop payment notices (along with payment bond claims) are your remedy.
Private Projects with Construction Loansโ
Use on private projects when a construction lender is involved:
- Served on the construction lender, not the owner
- Freezes undisbursed loan funds
- Must be served before the lender disburses remaining funds
Most large commercial projects in Silicon Valley have construction loans. A bonded stop payment notice served on the lender is extremely effective โ the lender MUST withhold funds, and the GC can't get paid until your claim is resolved.
On private work, you typically use both lien AND stop payment notice for maximum leverage.
Types of Stop Noticesโ
Unbonded Stop Noticeโ
- No bond required
- Must be released if disputed
- Less powerful
- Good for preliminary protection
Bonded Stop Noticeโ
- You post bond (typically 125% of claim)
- Cannot be released without resolution
- Owner/lender must withhold funds
- Much more powerful
- Costs money (bond premium)
Stop Notice Requirementsโ
Who Can Serveโ
- General contractors
- Subcontractors
- Sub-subcontractors
- Material suppliers
- Equipment lessors
Preliminary Noticeโ
Most states require:
- Preliminary notice before stop notice
- Served within 20 days of starting work
- Protects your right to serve stop notice
Check your state's requirements!
Timingโ
Serve within:
- During the project: Usually any time
- After completion: Check state deadline (often 30-90 days)
Key dates to track:
- Your last day of work
- Project completion date
- Stop notice deadline
How to Serve a Stop Noticeโ
Step 1: Verify Eligibilityโ
- Preliminary notice sent (if required)
- Within deadline
- Valid claim (money owed)
- Proper claimant (performed work or supplied materials)
Step 2: Prepare the Noticeโ
Include:
- Claimant name and address
- Project description and location
- Name of person who hired you
- General contractor name
- Description of work or materials
- Amount claimed
- Statement that claim is unpaid
Step 3: Serve the Noticeโ
Serve on:
- Public owner (agency)
- And/or construction lender
- Often: GC as well (courtesy copy)
Service methods:
- Personal delivery
- Certified mail, return receipt
- Follow state requirements exactly
Step 4: If Bondedโ
- Obtain stop notice bond
- Attach bond to stop notice
- Increases your leverage significantly
Stop Notice Process Timelineโ
Day 1: Work performed, not paid
โ
Day 30: Invoice past due
โ
Day 45: Demand letter sent
โ
Day 60: Still unpaid - serve stop notice
โ
Day 65: Owner receives, withholds funds
โ
Day 90: GC disputes or pays
โ
Resolution: Payment, settlement, or lawsuit
Stop Notice vs. Mechanics Lienโ
| Feature | Stop Notice | Mechanics Lien |
|---|---|---|
| Applies to | Public + private with lender | Private property |
| Attaches to | Funds | Property |
| Requires foreclosure | No | Yes |
| Preliminary notice | Usually required | Usually required |
| Bond option | Yes | Some states |
| Recovery | From withheld funds | From property sale |
California-Specific Rulesโ
Public Works (Civil Code ยงยง9350-9364)โ
| Rule | Detail |
|---|---|
| Preliminary notice required | Within 20 days of first furnishing |
| Deadline (with NOC) | 30 days after Notice of Completion recorded |
| Deadline (no NOC) | 90 days from cessation of work |
| Unbonded effect | Public entity should withhold, but may release if GC disputes |
| Bonded effect | Public entity MUST withhold โ cannot release without resolution |
| Bond amount | 125% of claim amount |
| Lawsuit deadline | 90 days after lien period expires |
Private Works with Lender (Civil Code ยงยง8500-8538)โ
| Rule | Detail |
|---|---|
| Preliminary notice required | Within 20 days of first furnishing |
| Served on | Construction lender (NOT the owner) |
| Unbonded effect | Lender may choose to withhold |
| Bonded effect | Lender MUST withhold undisbursed loan funds |
| Bond amount | 125% of claim amount |
| Freezes | Undisbursed construction loan funds |
Prompt Payment Interactionโ
If you've served a stop payment notice AND the GC is violating California's prompt payment laws (Civil Code ยงยง8800-8814), you have additional leverage:
- GC owes 2% per month penalty on wrongfully withheld amounts
- Undisputed amounts must be paid regardless of disputes on other items
- Document the prompt payment violation in your demand letter
When to Use Stop Noticesโ
Good Candidatesโ
- Public project, significant amount owed
- Private project with construction loan
- You've sent preliminary notice
- Negotiations have failed
- Deadline approaching
Think Twiceโ
- Small amounts (bond cost not worth it)
- Working relationship you want to preserve
- Dispute about quality (claim may be reduced)
- You missed preliminary notice deadline
Effectiveness and Leverageโ
Why Stop Notices Workโ
- Owner withholds payment from GC
- GC can't get paid until resolved
- GC pressure increases to pay you
- Funds are available when resolved
Bonded vs. Unbondedโ
Unbonded:
- Owner may release if GC disputes
- Weaker leverage
- No cost to you
- Good for initial pressure
Bonded:
- Owner MUST withhold
- Cannot release until resolved
- Costs 1-2% of claim
- Maximum leverage
Common Mistakesโ
1. Missing Preliminary Noticeโ
Problem: Stop notice may be invalid without it Solution: Always serve prelim within 20 days
2. Missing Deadlineโ
Problem: Stop notice rights expire Solution: Track all deadlines from day one
3. Improper Serviceโ
Problem: Notice may be invalid Solution: Follow exact service requirements
4. Wrong Amountโ
Problem: Inflated claims lose credibility Solution: Claim actual amount owed
5. Not Following Upโ
Problem: Stop notice sits without action Solution: Follow with demand, then lawsuit if needed
After Serving Stop Noticeโ
If They Payโ
- Verify payment clears
- Provide release of stop notice
- Provide lien waiver
- Document resolution
If They Disputeโ
- Review their objections
- Negotiate if appropriate
- Consider mediation
- File lawsuit to enforce if needed
Release of Stop Noticeโ
Provide release when:
- You've been paid in full
- You've settled
- Claim was invalid
Use proper form - same formality as stop notice